The best reason to think you've been left alone is how quiet everything is. No voice corrects a bad thought before it turns into a bad act, and the sky says nothing. On most days the only people who notice what you do are the ones standing close enough to see it. From there it's a short step to concluding that your life is yours to run, with no one in particular looking on.
It's a fair inference, and it runs into a few awkward facts. You can lie where nobody could catch you and still feel it afterwards. You can do someone a kindness they'll never trace to you and feel oddly settled. A creature built only to eat and reproduce would have no use for either reaction, since guilt after an unseen theft helps nobody survive. It just costs sleep.
An exam hall is silent too, and the silence is part of the exam. A host who steps back to let a guest choose hasn't left the house.
βDoes this human being suppose that they will be left unattended?β β The Seventeenth Flash
Nursi asks this as a question, and there's a comparison behind it. Everything else in the world, down to the wing of a fly, is made with exact care, and it would be strange if the care stopped at the one creature able to know about it, choose against it and answer for the choice.
You didn't author yourself, and you can't quite treat your choices as weightless either. Both are true, and it's reasonable to wonder what could hold the two together.